In about 10 days “Watchmen” will finally hit theaters (the movie poster with the big blue man on it). I say ‘finally’ because Watchmen has been a potential movie project for two decades now, having gone through several studios and directors. If you’ve read the book, you know why. Watchmen is, and always will be regardless of how well it does in theaters, the novel that can never truly be translated to film. So what are we to expect?
Well, from the following review it seems Watchmen is going to meet or exceed most expectations.
This is probably not the first you’ve read or heard about the Watchmen, even if you haven’t read the source material. It’s not Jane Austen being put to film here, this IS the holy grail of comics and has been for over 20 years. Geeky as it may be, many people are excited, anxious or unknowing. Read any blog discussion (there are several) and you can gauge the excitement. Some are even organizing dinner parties to discuss it. Meanwhile, mainstream sites fight for exclusive clips, every one of them watched eagerly by fans. There’s that much of a following, and for good reason. To read Watchmen is to become an instant fan. It doesn’t matter if you just tried it for the first time or you’re a well versed comic scholar, Watchmen is the greatest piece of graphic literature ever committed to paper. It is the Gold standard. It is…the Beatles.
Enough hyperbole though, let’s discuss what we might subject ourselves to in a couple of days.
Taking the optimistic angle, which seems to be most people’s approach, it’ll be another entertaining Hollywood blockbuster. It won’t be a PG hit to attract kids, but rather a gritty R rated spectacle…instantly a cultural phenomenon. It might get a new generation to read the original work, elevating the literary worth of the comic as the Dark Knight and first X-men movies have done.
Pessimistically, Snyder might utterly fail to meet the expectations of us spoiled comic brats and our overinflated expectations. To be fair, how do you tell someone how to enjoy something they love? It will be difficult to accept a literary masterpiece getting turned into a simplified blockbuster.
The Watchmen project is filled with these paradoxes. On one end it’s an amazing piece of visual art and requires a visionary to bring it to screen. In that regard, it’s a good thing they put the guy who did 300 on it. On the other hand, it’s dense with intelligent dialogue, complex plot twists and deep philosophies…so why did they put the guy who did 300 on it?
I intend to watch Watchmen with an open mind, a few grains of salt and a lot of hope. I can’t expect too much, but at the same time, I know how much great material there is to be translated to film.
One final note: I’m not one for spoilers, but the F.S.R. review did mention one line that bothered me:
“…while an omission from the source has been wisely altered to make the ending a tad more palatable though the true end result is exactly the same”
When Snyder first took the helm on this project, people immediately speculated and predicted which aspects of the novel he’d drop, “interpret” or just plain change. I’m rational enough to admit that plenty of the things about the novel could go for the sake of realistically creating a movie, but I’ve always stood by one conclusion about the Watchmen: Don’t touch the ending! The exact events, the fate of the characters and the very last image of the book tie the whole story together. Now, despite this opinion, it’s been confirmed that Snyder has taken the opposite route. Without giving anything away this alternative ending, according to some, is as equally strong as the original…we’ll see.
See you all on the 6th, good luck Mr. Snyder